I don't need encrypted email and all the hassle that goes along with that. That's not my threat model (and it wouldn't help since 50%+ of my email goes to Google and Microsoft anyway ...).
All I want is an email provider somewhere that will actually force someone to show up in person with a subpoena rather than turn over all my emails to a random bureaucrat who waggles some electrons suggestively.
However, if you don't like fastmail, who would you recommend instead?