> Think of the better art assets that were needlessly left behind.

Consider how long it takes to edit or recreate art assets to reduce their size. Depending on the asset, you might be basically starting over from scratch. Rewriting code to reduce its size is likely to be an even worse option, introducing new bugs and possibly running slower to boot. At least smaller, simpler art assets are likely to render faster.

This is also the kind of problem that's more likely to occur later in the schedule, when time is even more scarce. Between these two factors (lack of time and amount of effort required to get art assets which are both decent looking and smaller), I think in practice you're actually more likely to get better quality art assets by having an artificially reduced memory budget from the outset.

I see it as a "Choose your problem." affair.

1. Deal with possibly multiple issues possibly involving multiple people with the politics that entails resulting in a lot of stress for all involved as any one issue could render it a complete failure.

2. Have extra space you can decide to optimise if you want. You could even have politics and arguments over what to optimise, but if nothing happens it all still works so there is a lot less stress.

I pick 2.

If it would be detected by profiling that does make the technique asymmetric in that it would only stick around if nobody profiled to find it.

Or if you didn’t have an understanding with the sort of people who would run the profiler...

Better PMs do this today by having buffer-features they can cut when needed. It'll handle the not-enough-memory issue as well as a meddlesome VP who think you're over-subscribed and wants you to cut to meet your dates.

Also, don't forget you're hearing decades-later retellings of someone else's story. I don't doubt that they trickled this extra space out as changing requirements mandated it, but that they kept from doing so until the team had actually reached a certain level of product-maturity and reclaimed all of their own waste first.

Remember that the PMs goal is to ship. Them blocking some assets but actually shipping is a success. Better 95% of the product than 0%.