Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
The Breakfast Manifesto: The New Science of the Loneliest Meal (nymag.com)
9 points by robg on June 8, 2008 | hide | past | favorite | 8 comments


Voted up not because of the interesting content, but because of the interesting subject. I find it very hard to settle on healthy food for breakfast. Cereals and grains should be it, but somehow my feeling has always been that they don't agree with me very well. By now I also try to avoid dairy products, which makes "cereals" even less appealing.

So I am curious what everybody is eating?


Answering that question is exactly where I found the article interesting, especially with regard to the glycemic index and cognitive functioning. It's one reason I've almost entirely cut juice and sugar from my morning intake because it nicely explains the mid-morning crash. Even lightly processed cereals are not very good for you. It seems to be much better (physically and mentally) to get complex carbs (look for more fiber and less sugar) with fresh fruit (for fiber and sweetness) and perhaps a bit of protein/fat (nuts are really, really good). But all that's much easier said when full than hungry!

My wife and I have been trying (and failing) to push our diets closer to Michael Pollan's latest mantra:

"Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants."

http://www.michaelpollan.com/indefense.php

Magazine treatment here: http://www.nytimes.com/2007/01/28/magazine/28nutritionism.t....


Well I thought the glycemic index was a trend two years ago, but maybe it is still going strong, I am not sure ;-)

I will take a second look at the "in defense for food" book. Have you read "The China Study", and do the books agree?


Nope, can't say I've read "The China Study". Sounds interesting though. Thanks.

The glycemic index, to me, simply means how our bodies respond to foods based on the time in which the nutrients are metabolized. I'm very interested in how that process corresponds to mental functioning. and unfortunately there hasn't been enough work done in that area. The work I had heard of is the referenced the oatmeal/cap'n crunch study.


Breakfast is by far my favorite meal of the day. I always wake up extra hungry and can't wait to eat something. I usually eat toast with peanut butter and honey or jam, a bit of fruit, and whatever else looks tasty. I always have a hard time understanding how people don't eat breakfast because I wake up sooooo hungry. I'm totally worthless if I don't eat breakfast.


I swear by the Starbucks Ham and Cheese breakfast sandwitch. They are really good, lots of protien, some fiber, little fat for 300some calories.

After a lot of trying out, that is the food that gives me energy keeps me less hungry until lunch.


Was anyone else disturbed by the phrase "nutritional science"?

Also, an uninteresting story. Maybe if pg was mentioned having breakfast...


You can always start an Ask PG thread about what he had for breakfast :-P Better yet, a poll asking us to guess what he had!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: